ToyWiz - Nanuet, New York

Matthew C.

Great store with most anything you'd need! I'm into Magic the Gathering and this place sure has a lot to offer. As well as events and helpful staff. 10/10 from me 👍

Deborah S.

I have placed several online orders with Toy Wiz and never disappointed. Prices are competitive with market. Items shipped securely and great customer service anytime I contacted them with questions. Will continue to order from them!

Barbara A. H.

Hey Matt, remember trick-or-trade Pokémon booster packs two or three years ago? your store bought them all out and we’re charging upwards over $40 per pack that retailed at 17.99 when I went in.….

The short young male employee that’s usually at the front used to be at the target every single Wednesday in Spring Valley on restock day buying everything he could- I saw him on the prismatic release day….

I tried to trade in Giratina alt art from lost origins back when it was only a $300 card and I got offered $75. No whitening with great centering….

Looking at your other low reviews it’s seems that others have had similar experiences and feedback.

Maybe you just took over but clearly you can’t handle criticism from guests.

This place always surprises me how they stay in business.

I ordered an item around Christmas time that I sent back because I happen to find it locally in the store. I never received my refund and I had to dispute it through PayPal because they claimed they never received the product back. It was an item exclusive to Kohl’s that they bought all the local stock up because they knew it would be popular around Christmas time.

In this location They charge way over market for items that are dropping in stores at the same time. They are feeding into the scalper mentality.

Iv also seen one of their employees trying to buy out all of the local target pokemon and other TCG stock claiming it was for their “kid”.
I’ve heard from other local stores like GameStop that they do this all the time.

Being that they sell TCG products, they shouldn’t be going to the local retail stores and purchasing everything out to sell it for three times MSRP when other collectors don’t even have a shot at it.

When trading items they offer you a laughable amount 30 to 40% sometimes of what the item is worth for them to sell it at 120% to someone else.

I don’t spend any more money with this business since I work extremely hard for my money and everything in this economy cost way too much. I would reconsider making a purchase with them if you’re looking for products in the future.

Gregory J.

I’m very surprised at some of these reviews that I have been reading. I have nothing but great service and customer support every time I’ve purchased something from them. And just now I had a couple questions about an order and the response and resolution was prompt and handled immediately. I would definitely give them a shot if you’re looking for authentic merchandise. Prices are good and I don’t think a few extra dollars for guaranteed items is sufficient enough to leave bad reviews. Just saying!!!!!

Matt T.

They have what youre looking for but expect to pay about 15-20 percent over market price for brand new product. I've been shopping there since it's been wizard world and lately the price are outrageous. They are taking advantage of customers. When the pokemon market crashes and they go back to selling at market or below I may return.

JJ R.

Have been there several times to buy & trade in cards. First time i was there trading in cards ,I dealt with the owner & he was fair with his offer & willing to negotiate a bit. Overall great experience. Other couple times I wasnt so lucky, the guy John had a bad attitude & didnt seem like he wanted to be bothered. Overall I dont think most employees get the essence of the hobby. There is barely any decent product & if they do have it, it was over priced. Rockland needs a new family owned card store that actually cares about the hobby as much they do making $

Amanda S.

Good if you are looking for Warhammer figurines (husband shops here a bit for that), but charges significantly over MSRP for Pokemon products. Example: a product that is sold at another retailer for $40 was priced at $120. There's no excuse to charge scalper prices if you have a distributor.

jonathan G.

I went there the 26th and bought a few packs of surging sparks while visiting my girls family for Christmas. While there I pulled a pretty good card and I went in to the store to show the worker because before I exited the building he told me he hopes I pull the card I got a variation of (pikachu ex). When going back in the worker gave me a top loader and just gave me great vibes all around! He was younger with curly brown hair, bro definitely deserves a raise the interaction was worth more than the cards value to me. Wish I lived closer to you guys I’d be there everyday!