American Legends - Scarsdale, New York

PhilYouIn

Came here with my grandson for a Topps ‘ripping’ event. They did the best they could in a small space that was hopelessly overcrowded. Perhaps if one of the half dozen employees was on the selling floor-all day-directing traffic, it would have been better organized. Place got very packed and uncomfortably hot. But again, they did the best that could be expected. Today was like Christmas Eve for the place.

Rafael C.

I stopped by American Legends for “Rip Night” and just missed Michael Rubin’s cameo—but the experience was still incredible! I was there with my two buddies and my child, introducing them to the world of card collecting, and the atmosphere was electric. The staff was warm, welcoming, and passionate about the hobby, making it a fantastic place for both newcomers and seasoned collectors. The energy in the shop creates the perfect environment for learning, trading, and having fun. I ended purchasing some protectors and my son a Pokemon set-up (binder, sheets, cars set) for his new collection. I’ll definitely be stopping by more often in the future!

Charles

Condescending talking worker (lady) said some things to me as I was asking questions about cards and new releases. Usually spend about 150-200 dollars at a time there but after that I politely told my son to grab a couple packs of whatever he wanted and went to get frozen yogurt next door. It took a lot not to say something back to her but for the sake of my son I would have. I spent me last $60 there that day. Good product there so I will give 3 stars.

DJ B.

Overpriced products in a disgusting excess of market price and other retailers. Distributors are not selling them products that released this month over 300% above retail, 20-30% above market.

There is a reason they are the only store that has a TON of pokemon product on shelves, their prices are way too high.

You're better off buying from resellers on Ebay or scalpers outside target, don't get scammed buying here.

Matthew W.

Staff was incredibly nice and helpful. Went in with my daughter to check out the store and buy something. Following the sale, the lady behind the counter asked my daughter if she liked collecting cards and gave her a bag full of cards which made her day.

THE U. M.

Nice card shop good selection but on the high end of prices.

Joe D.

Absolutely amazing. Was loads of fun getting to jump back into cards, 80s and 90s style 🔥🔥🔥

I just found out cards are a thing again. Donna took the time to share her wealth of knowledge about how I should go about valuing my collection. 💲🤔❓

The best part was reliving some of my sports memories from childhood.

I found their prices extremely reasonable, and Donna even steered me away from pricier options and helped me get the most value for my money.

I got some hobby boxes from the 90s and can't wait to open them. Even if you could find a slightly cheaper price online like some say, American Legends is by far your better option, for a few reasons.

1) You can't even put a price on their knowledge. It's invaluable, and well worth the small markup. The advice probably saved me dozens of hours sorting through what I have.

2) They have an awesome staff that's fun to talk to, about baseball cards, basketball cards or anything else sports.

3) They're right here in Westchester, NY helping to support our community. Plus, they're trustworthy. And local if you ever have a problem.

Definitely worth stopping by, relive some memories about cards and then go home, and rub it in your parents face that you weren't just throwing away your money as a kid😜👌

Nathan L.

Great store with a large variety of cards not a lot of great singles but a lot of amazing wax to rip. My go to card shop.